Women Pay More for Home Loans, Study Finds

A new study by the Consumer Federation of America found that in 2005, about a third of women took out mortgages with interest rates over 7.66 percent (well above the average prime mortgage rate of 5.87 percent) compared with about a quarter of men.

The study, which examined 4.4 million mortgage originations throughout the country where borrowers identified by their gender, also found that women with high incomes were 46.4 percent more likely than men with comparable incomes to have the more expensive mortgages.

Although women earning below the area median income were 8 percent more likely to receive subprime loans than similarly earning men, women earning more than double the area median income were 50 more likely to receive subprime loans than men with similar earnings.

Critics say the research suggests that lenders are taking more than stated risk factors into consideration.

“The high levels of subprime lending among women compromise their ability to steadily accrue equity by paying off their mortgage – one of the easiest and most effective pathways to building wealth in America,” said Nancy Register, Associate Director of Consumer Federation of America and National Director of America Saves, a social marketing campaign to encourage lower- and moderate-income households to save and build wealth.

California Mortgage Bankers Association spokesman Dustin Hobbs defended the lending practices of the industry, stressing that Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data cannot explain everything. "It will show there is a disparity but not why there is a disparity," says Hobbs.

Source: Consumer Federation of America; Inside Bay Area, Eve Mitchell (12/08/06)